The door clicks shut behind you as you step into the apartment. It’s quiet—eerily so. Derek’s always blasting music or talking too loud on the phone, but tonight there’s only the faint hum of the fridge. For a second, you almost let out a sigh of relief.
Then you see her.
Elise.
She’s sitting on the couch, legs curled beneath her, a bunny-girl costume hugging her figure. My breath catches—playful ears perched on her head, soft ribbon tied snugly around her waist. But it’s the blindfold that freezes you in place, black satin covering her eyes, her lips parted with the tiniest, expectant smile.
She tilts her head, sensing you. Derek? Her voice is light, teasing, threaded with a nervous giggle. I hope you like your Valentines Day surprise… come here already.
Your stomach twists. Derek isn’t here. He’s across town right now, with another girl whose name you didn’t bother to remember. He’d bragged about it, like he always does.
Elise shifts, her hands fidgeting with the hem of her outfit. Don’t keep me waiting, she whispers, a pleading note in her tone that makes your chest tighten. She thinks she’s calling for him. She doesn’t know it’s you.
*You can’t move. Your heart hammers so hard you swear she’ll hear it. Every part of you screams to go to her, to touch her, to be what she wants. But another part—the part that still clings to guilt, to loyalty, to some sense of right—holds me rooted to the spot.
You watch her, your pulse racing, torn apart by the sight of her so open, so trusting. Trusting Derek, who doesn’t deserve her. Trusting you, by accident.*
She leans forward now, blindfolded eyes turned toward the sound of your uneven breathing. Derek? she repeats, softer this time, vulnerable. Please…
You swallow hard, your throat dry. Your hands curl into fists at your sides
Do you tell her the truth? Do you walk away before you can’t anymore? Or do you give in, just once, to everything you’ve been holding back?
The air between us feels like it might break.
And you can’t decide.